Baker’s Choice Mystery Dozen
Caramel Stroop Waffle
Pumpkin Spice Butterscotch
Cadbury Crème Cookies
Candy Cane- The perfect mix of peppermint and white chocolate drizzeld with red and white chocolate and topped with crushed candy canes .
White Chocolate Mac- White chocolate cranberry macadamia nut cookies that are balanced perfectly between the right amount of sweet and salty and soft and crunchy. *Please select if you’d like to add cranberries or not. These cookies contain nuts.
Cinnamon Crunch Cookies- This heavenly snickerdoodle-like cookie is a generous and delicious mix of cinnamon and sugar topped off with a crunchy fan favorite Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal.
Red Velvet - Classic Red Velvet flavors with a Butter & Batter twist. A n unbelievably soft centered cookie stuffed with white chocolate chips.
PB & Jam- Allllll the peanut butter & jelly! Topped off with a Nutter Butter cookie and a dollop of jam.
Chocolate Caramel Drops- This perfectly rich chocolate and caramel based cookie is filled with Rolo brand candy chunks creating a gooey, delicious treat. Of course we’ve topped it with a full Rolo right to expand on that flavor profile!
Oatmeal Raisin- A balanced ratio of hearty oats, plump raisins, and a dash of cinnamon to bring home that soft, melt-in-your-mouth taste of an oatmeal raisin cookie. We have turned non-raisin fans into fans with this cookie!
Aloha - Pineapple, shredded coconut, and crushed macadamia nut all packed together and dipped in chocolate to bring a little of the sweet island vibe.
Magic Pebbles- This top seller brings a powerful fruity, tangy punch to your mouth with yet another childhood favorite. With just the right amount of sweetness, this soft, tangy, and chewy cookie will have you reaching for more!
Caramel Stroop Waffle- When we can not fly as much these days, we bring the flight to you. With these delicious cookies FULL of soft Stroopwafles cookie bits , caramel, and topped off with a StroopWafle chunk and drizzled with more caramel.
Captain Crunch- So much texture in this cookie, with all the softness of the dough and perfect crunch in every bite. Filled with crushed Captain Crunch cereal, sprinkled with nonpareils, and topped with a crunch from the best part of all- Captain Crunch Berries.
Monster Mash- Monster Mash is a mash up of all your favorite ingredients in this classic cookie. My best friend, Krisse, makes these every year and has for at least 15 years. These are a tribute to her! Peanut butter, M&Ms, chocolate chips, and oatmeal with my own Butter & Batter twist on the cookie base.
Marshmallow Honeycomb- Gooey marshmallow mixed with sweet honeycomb cereal- a combo you never knew you loved.
Snickers Bomb- An explosive mix of deliciousness. This cookie is loaded with peanuts, caramel, chocolate, and Snickers bars.
Lemon Poppy Seed- Lemon lovers!! These Lemon Poppy Seed specialty cookies are full of the perfect amount of tangy lemon and sweetness 🍋
Pumpkin Spice Butterscotch- Welcome Fall!! Pumpkin and all the spice, mixed with butterscotch to give it a bit of a pop! A nice soft center with a muffin like texture.
Chocolate Pebbles- That new, new! Chocolate Lovers…..Chocolate chip cookies dipped in a decadent chocolate and rolled in Coco Pebbles to give it that light, texture and crunch!
PBC Cookies- Amazing PB deliciousness that doesn’t disappoint. These cookies are irresistible and have all things peanut butter- Reese’s Pieces, peanut butter, peanut butter chips, and a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup to top it all off! This cookie does contain peanuts.
Sugared Ginger- With all the spice and everything nice, this cookie was made for fall!
S'mores- Smores cookies packed with Golden Grahams, marshmallows, chocolate chips, and graham crackers give this cookie a beautifully textured bite- you won’t even miss the skewer.
Salted Triple Chocolate Chip- A gooey, mouthwatering and perfectly sweet and salty treat for chocolate lovers of all kind. This cookie is loaded with three different types of chocolate!
Mint Chip- For those mint lovers out there: This chocolatey, gooey Mint Chip cookie is full of Andes Mint chunks- sure to satisfy your mint cravings.
Cookies & Cream- This cookie you will find chunks upon chunks of Oreo cookies all mixed together with creamy, gooey, marshmallows and topped off with the cutest mini Oreo cookie!
Cookie Butter- All things cookie butter. This dough is loaded with Lotus Biscoff cookie bits and cookie butter and then injected with even more gooey, creamy cookie butter. You won’t want to miss this hit!
Toffee Pecan- This newbie for the holidays is a mixture of buttery bits of toffee, crunchy pecans, and chocolate chips, all dipped in a decadent chocolate and sprinkled with toffee and pecans for added texture.
M&M- Your favorite brand candy, M&Ms, that change colors with the respective holidays!
Birthday Cake- This is a holiday show-stopper. The warmth of the holidays all wrapped up in a cookie; what more can you ask for!Outside of the holidays? No problem, request no sprinkles or add a special color of sprinkles for any occasion ❤️
Circus Cookie- Mother’s Animal Circus Cookies with white chocolate chips. The right amount of texture mixed with the memories of yesterday.
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip- A balanced ratio of hearty oats, chocolate chips, and a dash of cinnamon to bring home that soft, melt-in-your-mouth taste of an oatmeal cookie. For lasting freshness, we recommend placing the cookies into an air tight container once opened.
Pandan- If you have not yet tried Pandan, what are you waiting for? This crinkle style cookie has a bold floral and sweet flavor that you need in your life.
German Chocolate-Better than your grandma's cake! This cookie is filled with decadent chocolate, pecans, and a creamy coconut German chocolate cake frosting. Hands down a favorite!
Cadbury Creme- One of our most popular seasonal selections. You better believe when Easter time comes around these babies will be back in stock. Filled with creme and mini Cadbury eggs, you will believe in that bunny again!